The little arrows on plastic do not mean recyclable
Turn over a yogurt tub, a water bottle or a takeaway lid and you will usually find three arrows chasing each other around a number. Most people read it the way it looks : this goes in the recycling bin.
That is not what it says. The number tells you which kind of plastic the item is made of. That helps the people who sort plastic, but it promises nothing. The standard behind the code says it does not imply that any system exists to collect or process the item. Whether anyone collects that plastic, sorts it and turns it into something new is decided somewhere else entirely, by the plant your local collector sends it to and by whether someone will buy what comes out.
An industry label that borrowed the recycling loop
The code was created in 1988 by the Society of the Plastics Industry, a US trade group. Its stated aim was to make used plastic easier to recycle by telling sorters what each item was made of. To do that, it put a digit inside the three-arrow loop that people already knew as the recycling sign.
In 2008, ASTM International, a body that writes technical standards, took over the code, and it now lives in a standard called D7611. In 2013 a revision replaced the chasing arrows with a plain solid triangle, so that the code would stop suggesting recycling, the very confusion this article is about. The standard was revised again in July 2026. Many products still carry the old arrows, because the standard does not require existing moulds to be changed.
ASTM itself is clear about this. The code is there to identify what resin an item is made of, not to say whether the product is recyclable.
What the numbers 1 to 7 actually name
1 is PET, the clear plastic of most drink bottles. 2 is HDPE, the stiffer plastic of milk jugs and detergent bottles. 3 is PVC. 4 is LDPE, the soft plastic of bags and films. 5 is PP, common in tubs and caps. 6 is polystyrene, the foam of cups and trays. 7 means everything else, including mixtures.
So 7 is not a seventh kind of plastic. It is a drawer for whatever does not fit the first six, which is why on its own the number tells a sorting plant very little about what the item is.

Even the best-recycled plastics come back about three times in ten
In the United States, the latest full national count by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is for 2018. That year, 29.1% of PET bottles and jars and 29.3% of natural HDPE bottles, such as milk jugs, were recycled. For all plastic containers and packaging together the figure was 13.6%, and for all plastics 8.7%. These rates are for those product groups, not for every item stamped #1 or #2.
Other counts tell a similar story, though they count different things. NAPCOR, an industry group for PET, puts the share of US PET bottles collected for recycling at 32.5% in 2023, revised from an earlier 33.0%, and at 30.2% in 2024. Greenpeace USA, an advocacy group, estimated what is actually reprocessed and reported lower figures for 2021 : 20.9% for PET, 10.3% for HDPE, and less than 5% for each of the other types, #3 to #7. Its headline estimate was that about 5% of US household plastic waste was recycled that year. The recycling industry disputes how that figure was calculated.
The counts differ because they measure at different points : what is collected, what a reprocessor buys, what ends up as new material. They agree on the shape. #1 and #2 bottles are the plastics most often recycled, and still most of them are not. The rest rarely are.

- EPA, Containers and packaging : product-specific data
- EPA, Plastics : material-specific data
- NAPCOR 2024 PET recycling report press release
- NAPCOR report portrays resiliency in North American PET industry (Recycling Today)
- Greenpeace USA, Circular Claims Fall Flat Again (2022 report)
- Plastic recycling a failed concept, Greenpeace study says (CBS News)
Your town decides, not the number
These are national averages. What happens to your tub depends on the sorting plant your collector uses, and plants differ. In Greenpeace's 2022 survey of 375 US sorting facilities, only #1 and #2 were widely accepted. PP tubs and containers were accepted at 52% of them, plastic clamshells at 11%, and bags and films at 1%. These are the survey's findings, not a rule for any one town.
So the same #5 tub can be wanted in one city and sent to landfill in the next. Only the local collection list can say which, and it is worth reading for the kind of item, not only the number : a #1 bottle and a #1 tray need not end up in the same place.

- Greenpeace USA, Circular Claims Fall Flat Again (2022 report)
- Most plastic is not recyclable, Greenpeace report finds (World Economic Forum)
- Plastic recycling a failed concept, Greenpeace study says (CBS News)
- ASTM D7611/D7611M, Standard practice for coding plastic manufactured articles for resin identification
California tried to tie the arrows to what is really recycled
In 2021 California passed a law known as SB 343. It allows the chasing arrows, or any other sign of recyclability, only on materials that are regularly collected and processed for recycling in the state. In practice, a material has to be collected by recycling programs that cover at least 60% of the state's population, and sorted by facilities that serve at least 60% of recycling programs statewide. A plastic item that misses that bar but must still show its resin code has to put the number inside a plain solid triangle instead of the arrows.
The state's recycling agency, CalRecycle, published the study that decides which materials qualify on 4 April 2025. That started the clock : the rules were to apply to products made after 4 October 2026. Before that date came, on 14 July 2026, a federal judge in San Diego issued a preliminary injunction that stops California's Attorney General from enforcing the law while a lawsuit by industry groups continues. The judge found the challengers likely to succeed in arguing that parts of the law are too vague and restrict speech more than needed. CalRecycle notes that the litigation may affect the deadline. The law is on hold, not repealed. In October 2026 the challengers asked to extend the case to SB 54, California's packaging law, and in the latest reports available for this article that request was still pending.
At the federal level, the Federal Trade Commission's Green Guides set the standard for calling a product recyclable, and the agency has been reviewing them since 2022. They say a plain "recyclable" claim is fair only when recycling facilities are available to a substantial majority of the consumers or communities where the item is sold, which the FTC sets at 60%. That is a rule about what a label may claim, not a measure of how much actually gets recycled.

- CalRecycle, Recycling labels (SB 343)
- Federal court enjoins enforcement of California's truth in recycling law (Hunton)
- How California's SB 343 is redefining recyclability labeling for packaging (Shorr)
- Federal court preliminarily enjoins California's SB 343 (Ashurst Perkins Coie)
- Federal court enjoins enforcement of California's truth in recycling law (Legal 500)
- California League of Food Producers lawsuit, SB 343 and SB 54 (Packaging Dive)
- FTC, Green Guides
- 16 CFR 260.12, Recyclable claims
The number is for the sorting plant
The arrows look like a promise, but the code was never one. It was a label for people who sort plastic, and it is useful to them, because it tells them what an item is made of. Whether that item gets a second life depends on what your collector accepts and what someone will pay for, and that changes from town to town and from year to year.
Next time someone says a container is recyclable because it has the arrows, you can tell them what the number actually says : which plastic it is, and nothing more.









